Simple Assessment Explained: The PA302 Letter and What to Do When the Figures Are Wrong
A Simple Assessment is HMRC telling you what it thinks you owe, not a return you file. You get 60 days to challenge the…
Compare the Income Tax you actually paid with what you should owe for the year.
Your total taxable income for the year (salary, pension etc.).
From your payslips, P60 or P45 (tax deducted - not National Insurance).
Left a job part-way through the year? PAYE often assumes you earned all year, so too much tax is taken.
effective tax rate
your top tax rate
Income Tax only - National Insurance is not refundable this way. Reclaim overpaid tax via your Personal Tax Account on gov.uk.
| Band | Rate | Income in band | Tax |
|---|---|---|---|
| Personal Allowance | 0% | £0 | |
| Total Income Tax due | |||
Where the green line sits above the blue line, you have likely overpaid.
| Scenario | Tax due | Tax paid | Refund / owed | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Enter your gross pay, the tax you've actually had deducted, and any allowable expenses into the tax refund calculator above. It compares what you paid against what you should have paid under the 2026/27 rules, and shows the likely difference. Treat the result as a guide for whether it's worth contacting HMRC, not as a guaranteed payout.
Most overpayments happen because PAYE is a blunt instrument. Your employer deducts tax based on the code HMRC gives them, and that code is only as accurate as the information HMRC holds. When something changes mid-year, the deductions often lag behind reality. Seeing too much tax come off your pay is frustrating, but in a lot of cases it's genuinely reclaimable.
The most common reasons you end up owed a tax refund are:
A PAYE refund estimate comes down to one comparison: the tax you should have paid on your real income, against the tax that was actually deducted. Put simply:
Refund (estimate) = Tax actually deducted − Tax correctly due on your income
To find the tax correctly due, the calculator rebuilds your bill from scratch using the 2026/27 figures. Everyone starts with a Personal Allowance of £12,570 - the slice you can earn before any income tax applies. Income above that is taxed in bands:
So the working order is: take your gross income, subtract your Personal Allowance to get taxable income, apply the band rates above, and that's the tax you genuinely owe. Subtract any allowable expenses from your income before you tax it, because expenses reduce the taxable figure rather than the tax directly. The gap between that correct figure and what landed on your payslips is your potential refund.
One important regional note: if you live in Scotland, your income tax is set by the Scottish Government and uses different rates and bands (starter, basic, intermediate, higher, advanced and top rates), although the £12,570 Personal Allowance is the same UK-wide. A refund worked out on rest-of-UK bands won't be accurate for a Scottish taxpayer, so use a Scotland-specific figure if that's you. National Insurance, by contrast, is calculated per pay period and is rarely refundable in the same way, so a true overpayment refund almost always relates to income tax.
Take Priya, a graphic designer who left one job in May 2026 and started a new role in July without handing over her P45. Her new employer puts her on an emergency code, taxing her as if July is the first month of the year and ignoring the two months she was out of work.
Over the 2026/27 year she earns £30,000 gross from the new job. Because of the emergency code, more tax came off in the early months than her real position justified. Let's check what she should owe:
If the emergency code caused £4,000 to be deducted across the year, Priya's estimated refund is £4,000 − £3,486 = £514. In practice HMRC usually corrects an emergency code automatically once it receives full pay details, and any overpayment is repaid - but it's worth checking rather than assuming it sorts itself out.
Now take Daniel, a nurse on £30,000 who washes his own uniform and occasionally drives between sites in his own car. He's already paid the right tax on his salary - £3,486 as above - but he's never claimed his allowable expenses.
Say his allowable expenses come to £500 over the year (a flat-rate uniform allowance plus some business mileage at HMRC's approved rate of 45p per mile for the first 10,000 miles). Expenses reduce taxable income, so:
It's a modest sum in one year, but you can usually backdate expense claims for up to four tax years, so a long-standing claim can be worth several hundred pounds. As a basic-rate taxpayer, the refund is simply 20% of the expenses you claim; a higher-rate taxpayer gets 40% relief on the same expenses.
These are the figures the calculator uses to rebuild your correct bill. They apply to England, Wales and Northern Ireland; Scotland has its own bands.
| Band | Taxable income (after allowance) | Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Personal Allowance | First £12,570 of income | 0% |
| Basic rate | £0 – £37,700 | 20% |
| Higher rate | £37,700 – £125,140 | 40% |
| Additional rate | Above £125,140 | 45% |
Source: gov.uk income tax rates, checked for the 2026/27 tax year. Note the Personal Allowance is reduced by £1 for every £2 you earn over £100,000 and disappears entirely at £125,140 - high earners who hit this taper sometimes find they've actually underpaid rather than overpaid.
Once the calculator suggests you might be owed money, the claim route depends on why. The good news is that claiming directly is free - you never have to pay a percentage to anyone.
You can start most claims at gov.uk's claim a tax refund service. If HMRC owes you money after the tax year, it often sends a P800 tax calculation automatically, and you can request the refund online or wait for a cheque.
Timing varies by claim type. An online refund through your personal tax account or a P800 can land in your bank within about five working days of you requesting it; a cheque takes longer, often a few weeks. Expense claims and Self Assessment refunds can take several weeks to process, especially around the January and April peaks. If you're still waiting well beyond that, it's worth chasing HMRC directly.
If your situation is more complex - multiple income sources, a high-earner allowance taper, or self-employment alongside a job - it's worth modelling your full position. Our income tax calculator rebuilds your whole bill from gross pay, and the emergency tax calculator shows exactly how much an emergency code costs you in a given month.
This tax refund calculator gives estimates for guidance only and isn't personal tax or financial advice; check your own figures with HMRC or a qualified adviser before acting.
This checks whether you have paid more Income Tax than you owed, which happens far more often than people realise. The most common cause is simply not working a full tax year — PAYE spreads your Personal Allowance evenly across twelve months, so if you leave a job in August you have only received part of an allowance you were entitled to in full.
Emergency tax codes on a new job, a first job partway through the year, and stopping work to study or travel all produce the same result. Refunds can be claimed for the previous four tax years, so it is worth checking several years back, not just this one.
To dig deeper into a possible refund, try the tax code calculator to confirm your code is right, the mileage allowance calculator to value business journeys in your own car, and the marriage allowance calculator if you or your partner could transfer part of your Personal Allowance.
A Simple Assessment is HMRC telling you what it thinks you owe, not a return you file. You get 60 days to challenge the…
You can normally take 25% of your pension as a tax-free lump sum, capped at £268,275. Here is exactly how the rule works…
Understand UK income tax rates and bands for 2026/27, including the Personal Allowance, the basic, higher and additional…
If you keep your own books, these are the packages that handle Self Assessment and Making Tax Digital.
The freelancer and contractor favourite, free with some bank accounts.
From £0 with a NatWest, RBS or Mettle account, otherwise about £19/mo
See FreeAgentThe big all-rounder with the deepest MTD track record.
From about £10/mo, frequent 90% off intro offers
See QuickBooksThe scale-up choice once you have staff, stock or VAT.
From about £15/mo
See XeroWe may earn a commission if you sign up through one of these links. It never changes what we calculate, what we recommend, or the order they appear in.